Tuesday, June 05, 2012

Object Model or Data Model - What comes first?

Throughout my career, I have asked this question multiple times to myself - what to model first? The database entities or the object model? Start with ER diagrams (conceptual, logical) or UML class diagrams.

Well, the answer is that - it depends. Many a times, it also depends on the culture of the organization. In many organizations, the 'data' teams are more strong and powerful and insist on ER modeling first. It is possible to run both these work-streams in parallel, as there is a lot of conceptual common-ness during the initial domain modeling. What bugs me is the differences in the semantics of UML and ER. Does not make sense to do both at the conceptual level.

Now over the past few years, there have been a plethora of ORM tools that bridge the object-relational impedance mismatch. These ORM tools have a host of features that allow us to just work with the object model and abstract away the creation of the data model.
For e.g. Entity Framework 4.0 has full support for 'code-first' approach that is detailed in this article.
I simply loved the 'convention-over-configuration' approach in EF 4.0. These features enable us to only work with the object model and not worry about the data schema at all. Such features would suffice for 70-80% of business cases, I believe. 

A snippet from the article will give the reader an idea of the abstraction that is provided -

In addition to supporting a designer-based development workflow, EF4 also enables a more code-centric option which we call “code first development”. Code-First Development enables a pretty sweet development workflow. It enables you to: 
  • Develop without ever having to open a designer or define an XML mapping file 
  • Define your model objects by simply writing “plain old classes” with no base classes required 
  • Use a “convention over configuration” approach that enables database persistence without explicitly configuring anything 
  • Optionally override the convention-based persistence and use a fluent code API to fully customize the persistence mapping

No comments:

Post a Comment